Am I wrong? / Couples

Am I wrong for being upset about phones at dinner?

I made his favorite meal. He laughed at a video the whole time. When I said something, he said I was on my phone "all the time too."

Please Settle This,

This is going to sound small. I promise you it does not feel small.

Devin and I both work long days. Dinner is the one time we actually sit across from each other. For the first two years, it was my favorite part of the day. We would talk about everything, the weird guy at his gym, my sister’s drama, what we would name a boat if we ever bought a boat. (The Settled Down. I still think that is a great name.)

Somewhere along the way, the phone joined us. First it was face down on the table. Then face up, "just in case work texts." Now it is propped against the salt shaker, playing videos.

Last Thursday I made his favorite: short ribs, three hours in the oven. I lit a candle. I put on the playlist from our first trip. He sat down, said "this looks amazing, babe," and then watched a man restore a rusty knife for twenty-five minutes. He laughed out loud twice. Not at anything I said.

I finally said, very calmly, "Could we maybe do dinner without phones?"

He put it down, looked at me, and said, "You are on yours all the time too. You were literally on it this morning in bed."

And here is the part that is eating me up: he is not completely wrong. I do scroll in bed. I check my email at red lights. But dinner was supposed to be ours. I did not think I needed to make a rule about it.

Now every dinner feels like a test. If I pick mine up to show him a photo, he raises his eyebrows. If he leaves his in the other room, he makes a big show of it, like he is doing me a favor.

Am I wrong for wanting dinner to be phone-free? Or am I being a hypocrite?

Signed,

Talking to the Top of His Head

Letters are written by NowSettled from the disputes people search for. Names and details are made up.

How would you handle it?

Tap one to see how everyone else answered.

Who was right?

Why Talking to the Top of His Head has a point

Dinner is the one time they really talk, and she put real effort into it. Wanting one screen-free half hour is not about the phone, it is about feeling like a priority.

Why Devin has a point

He has watched her scroll in bed and at red lights, so a rule that only lands on him feels like a double standard, and like he is being graded at his own table.

The conclusion

See who was right

Free with your email. The same free account as the quizzes, and it works in the app.

Free quizzes for this

Every quiz is free. Some just ask for the free account.

More couples letters

See every letter

Got your own letter?

Settle it for real. You each tell your side, privately, and get one fair decision you can both live with. Free to start.

It's better in the app

Quizzes, challenges, training and live resolutions. Free.

Get the app