Am I wrong? / Coworkers

Am I wrong for not answering work messages after hours?

11:42 pm on a Saturday: "Quick question." By Monday, she had told our manager I was "hard to reach."

Please Settle This,

I need an outside opinion from people who do not work at my company, because everyone who does is scared.

I work on a team of five. My coworker Rachel is talented, fast and, I genuinely think, a workaholic. She messages at all hours. Not emails. Direct messages, with the little notification sound.

Wednesday, 9:15 pm: "Hey, quick question about the deck." Friday, 10:30 pm: "Did you see my notes?" Saturday, 11:42 pm: "Quick question." Then, at 11:58 pm: "???"

For the first few months, I answered all of them. I was new, and I wanted to look committed. I answered from my sister’s wedding. I answered from the dentist’s chair. My partner started calling my phone "Rachel."

This summer, I stopped. Not in a dramatic way. I just started replying the next morning at 9, first thing, every time. Nothing was ever late. Nothing ever broke.

On Monday our manager pulled me into a "quick sync." Apparently Rachel had mentioned I am "hard to reach on the weekends" and that it "slows things down." My manager said it nicely. He said "no pressure." But he said it.

Here is the thing: I do not think Rachel is trying to get me in trouble. I think she truly believes that answering at midnight is what good work looks like. And maybe at this company, it is.

Am I wrong for logging off? Or is answering at midnight just the cost of keeping my job?

Signed,

Off the Clock

Letters are written by NowSettled from the disputes people search for. Names and details are made up.

How would you handle it?

Tap one to see how everyone else answered.

Who was right?

Why Off the Clock has a point

Nothing was ever late, and replies came first thing every morning. Time off that is actually off is reasonable, and most work can wait eight hours.

Why Rachel has a point

She works on her own schedule and truly believes speed is what good work looks like. Waiting on someone at night can feel to her like the work is stuck.

The conclusion

See who was right

Free with your email. The same free account as the quizzes, and it works in the app.

Free quizzes for this

Every quiz is free. Some just ask for the free account.

More coworkers letters

See every letter

Got your own letter?

Settle it for real. You each tell your side, privately, and get one fair decision you can both live with. Free to start.

It's better in the app

Quizzes, challenges, training and live resolutions. Free.

Get the app