Am I wrong? / Families

Am I wrong for not hosting Thanksgiving this year?

Five years. Twenty-two people. One sister who brings rolls still in the bag. This year, I said no.

Please Settle This,

For five years, Thanksgiving has happened at my house. Not because anyone voted. Because the first year my mom’s knee was bad, I said "I will do it," and in my family, once you do something once, it is your job until you die.

Every year it is twenty-two people. I start brining the turkey on Tuesday. I take Wednesday off work. I own folding chairs that live in my garage 364 days a year. My sister Denise brings rolls. Store-bought. Still in the bag.

Last year, after everybody left, I sat down on the kitchen floor at midnight next to a sink full of roasting pans, and I just stayed there. My husband found me and said, "Babe, you do not have to do this." And I realized he was right. I did not have to. I just always had.

So in September I texted the family group chat: "Love you all, but I am taking a year off from hosting. Who wants Thanksgiving?"

Silence. Two full days of silence. Then Denise replied: "So you are just canceling Thanksgiving?"

Then my aunt sent a crying emoji. Then my mom called and said, "Your grandmother would be heartbroken," which is wild, because my grandmother hosted exactly zero Thanksgivings in her entire life.

Now it is October and nobody has offered. Denise says I am "holding the holiday hostage." My mom keeps sending me turkey recipes "just in case." Part of me feels guilty. Part of me wants to book a cabin in the mountains and turn my phone off until December.

Am I wrong for stepping back? Or is this just the price of being the one who holds the family together?

Signed,

Done Basting

Letters are written by NowSettled from the disputes people search for. Names and details are made up.

How would you handle it?

Tap one to see how everyone else answered.

Who was right?

Why Done Basting has a point

Five years, twenty-two people and two days off work, every single year, with no one else taking a turn. Asking for help is not canceling anything.

Why Denise has a point

To her, Thanksgiving is her sister’s house. Without it she does not know where the family goes, and she is scared the whole thing falls apart.

The conclusion

See who was right

Free with your email. The same free account as the quizzes, and it works in the app.

Free quizzes for this

Every quiz is free. Some just ask for the free account.

More families letters

See every letter

Got your own letter?

Settle it for real. You each tell your side, privately, and get one fair decision you can both live with. Free to start.

It's better in the app

Quizzes, challenges, training and live resolutions. Free.

Get the app