Am I wrong? / Friends

Am I wrong for canceling plans when I am exhausted?

I bailed on her birthday drinks an hour before. She texted back: "You always do this. It is starting to feel personal."

Please Settle This,

My best friend Nia and I have been friends since we were eleven. She has seen me through two breakups, a cross-country move and a very bad haircut. I would take a bullet for her.

I just apparently will not take an Uber for her.

Here is what happened. Nia’s birthday drinks were Friday at 8. I had just finished the worst week of my year: a project deadline, my landlord ignoring a leak, my dad in the hospital for two nights (he is okay now). By Friday at 7, I was on the floor of my apartment in my work clothes, staring at the ceiling, and I could not make myself get up.

So I texted her: "I am so sorry, I am completely wiped, I cannot make it tonight. Happy birthday, I love you, lunch next week on me?"

She texted back twenty minutes later: "You always do this. It is starting to feel personal."

And that is the part that hurt, because when I counted, she was not completely wrong. I canceled on her concert in the spring. I left her housewarming after forty minutes. I rescheduled our brunch twice.

But none of that was about her. I am tired. I am tired in a way sleep does not fix. And I thought, out of everyone, my best friend of seventeen years would understand that.

I have not replied yet. Every draft either sounds like an excuse or like a fight.

Am I wrong for canceling when I genuinely have nothing left? Or have I been a bad friend without realizing it?

Signed,

Running on Empty

Letters are written by NowSettled from the disputes people search for. Names and details are made up.

How would you handle it?

Tap one to see how everyone else answered.

Who was right?

Why Running on Empty has a point

It was a brutal week, including her dad in the hospital, and she had nothing left. Resting instead of showing up empty is not a crime against friendship.

Why Nia has a point

It was her birthday, and it was not the first cancellation this year. After enough last-minute texts, it stops feeling like bad timing and starts feeling like a ranking.

The conclusion

See who was right

Free with your email. The same free account as the quizzes, and it works in the app.

Free quizzes for this

Every quiz is free. Some just ask for the free account.

More friends letters

See every letter

Got your own letter?

Settle it for real. You each tell your side, privately, and get one fair decision you can both live with. Free to start.

It's better in the app

Quizzes, challenges, training and live resolutions. Free.

Get the app